Guide

Hire a Payroll Person or Use a Payroll Team: What Each Includes

Count salary, taxes, benefits, recruiting and backup coverage, then compare the full cost of a hire with a quote for a payroll team, scoped to your work.

Hands turning pages in a binder of paperwork

At a glance

A second payroll review built into our process

Backup coverage when someone is out

Federal, state and local tax filings handled

You approve every run

The full cost of a hire

What does one payroll hire really cost?

Payroll and timekeeping clerks, the closest occupation BLS tracks, earned a national median of $58,260 a year in May 2025. The middle half earned $47,990 to $69,600.

Wages are only part of the cost. BLS reports that benefits, including legally required payroll taxes, made up 30.0% of private employers’ compensation costs in June 2026.

What the full cost of a hire includes:

Salary or hourly wages

Benefits such as health insurance and retirement

Recruiting, onboarding and training

Cover for time off, and hiring again after turnover

A part-time hire

What a part-time hire covers, and what it does not

A part-time hire can cover a straightforward payroll. You still need a plan for review, time off and work outside their scheduled hours.

Before you hire, decide who covers these five situations.

Five questions to answer first

1.

Who reviews the payroll before it goes out?

2.

Who runs payroll when vacation or sick days fall on a pay date?

3.

Who answers multi-state tax questions beyond what they have handled before?

4.

Who handles year-end work and agency notices between their scheduled days?

5.

Who keeps the payroll knowledge when they leave?

Side by side

How do a part-time hire, a full-time hire and a payroll team compare?

Part-time payroll hire

Full-time payroll hire

A PayAdvisors payroll team

Who does the work

An employee, part of the week

An employee, full time

A team of payroll professionals

Time to start

Recruiting, then training

Recruiting, then training

Phased onboarding, then your first live payroll with us

What you pay for

Wages, payroll taxes, recruiting

Wages, payroll taxes, benefits, recruiting, training

One quote, scoped to your payroll

Management load

You manage the person

You manage the person

We manage the work

When to hire

What our clients say

“Of all the consultants that I’ve actually had, I’d say PayAdvisors has been the best. And I think one of the reasons is that it’s not just a single person, it’s a team behind me.”

Melanie Toliver

President, The Hopkins Group

Frequently asked questions

How does the cost compare with hiring a payroll person?

We scope a team for your payroll on your first call. You can compare that with the full cost of hiring, including salary, benefits, recruiting and coverage. A team also runs every pay run, five days a week, and does not leave when one person does.

When should a business outsource payroll?

When payroll depends on one person, when you add employees in new states, or when errors and notices keep coming back.

Do we have to switch payroll systems?

No. We run payroll inside the payroll system you already use, so there is nothing to migrate.

Is a managed payroll firm the same as ADP or Paychex?

No. ADP and Paychex provide the payroll system. PayAdvisors is a team of payroll and HR professionals who run payroll inside the payroll system you already use, as your payroll team.

See how they compare side by side: PayAdvisors vs ADP and Paychex. Or compare all the ways to outsource payroll.

How does PayAdvisors scope the work?

We scope it on your first call, based on the payroll work the team takes on.

How long does onboarding take?

Onboarding runs in phases. First, we learn your current payroll setup and processes. Next, our team takes over payroll in your payroll system and runs your first live payroll with you. After that, we move into ongoing payroll and look for ways to improve your setup.

Get in touch

Tell us how we can help with your payroll or HR. A member of our team will reach out shortly.

What happens next

1.

Send the form with your name, email, company and how you heard about us. Phone, company website and a note on how we can help are optional.

2.

Our team reads your message and reaches out.

3.

If payroll can't wait, get started and tell us your next pay date.

Other ways to reach us

Monday through Friday

Prefer to pick a time? See the calendar

Talk with our team

See how we use the details you send in our privacy policy.

Next step

Compare it with your own numbers

Tell us about your payroll, and we will scope it on the first call. There is no obligation.