Hiring Your First Employee: The Payroll Setup Checklist

A desk with a stack of blank new-hire forms, a pen and a laptop, ready for a first employee's payroll setup

Before your first employee's first payday, you need an EIN, state withholding and unemployment accounts, workers' compensation coverage where your state requires it, a completed Form W-4, Form I-9 and any state withholding form, a new-hire report to your state, and a set pay schedule. After that, every payday means withholding and depositing taxes on time, and every quarter means filing payroll returns.

A payroll team can set this up with you before the first payday.

This checklist walks through the payroll setup steps for a first employee, in the order most owners need them. It covers payroll setup only; it is not tax, legal, or insurance advice.

Payroll setup for your first employee at a glance

StepWhat to have in placeWhen
Federal tax accountEmployer Identification Number (EIN) and EFTPS enrollment so you can deposit federal taxes and later confirm those depositsBefore the first payday; apply for the EIN first
State tax accountsState income-tax withholding account (if your state has withholding) and state unemployment insurance accountBefore the first payday; start early, because timing varies by state
ClassificationA clear decision that the person is an employee or an independent contractorBefore work starts, not after the first payment
New-hire formsForm W-4, Form I-9, and any state withholding formW-4 before the first paycheck; I-9 on the timeline below
New-hire reportReport the hire to your state's new-hire directoryFederal rule is 20 days; some states are shorter
Pay setupA regular pay schedule, and workers' compensation coverage if your state requires itBefore the first day of work
First runsWithhold, deposit, and later file the quarterly federal and state returnsEach payday, then each quarter

If you want a payroll team to set this up and run it with you, see our payroll startup package.

What do you need before you hire your first employee?

You can make an offer before every account is open, but you should not run the first payday until the items in the table above are in place. The IRS treats you as an employer once you have employees, and it expects you to withhold, deposit, and file on time even if you only have one person on payroll.

Two things are easy to leave too late:

  1. State tax accounts. Withholding and unemployment registration is done with your state, not with the IRS, and each state has its own form or online application. Our state payroll tax registration guides walk through those accounts state by state.
  2. A pay schedule you can actually keep. Pick paydays you can meet every time (for example weekly or biweekly) and stick to them. Missing a payday after someone has started work is a much harder problem than moving a start date.

Step 1: Get your federal and state tax accounts

Get an EIN. If you do not already have an Employer Identification Number, apply on the IRS website. The EIN identifies your business on federal payroll returns, deposits, and Forms W-2. Do not use a Social Security number in place of an EIN.

Enroll in EFTPS. Federal tax deposits must be made by electronic funds transfer. The IRS points employers to the Electronic Federal Tax Payment System (EFTPS) so you can make deposits and later confirm that they posted under your EIN. Enroll early enough that the enrollment is active before the first deposit is due.

Open the state accounts. In most states you will need:

  • A state income-tax withholding account, if the state taxes wages
  • A state unemployment insurance account

Some cities or localities also require withholding. Start this when you know the hire is real, because each state sets its own processing time. Have the EIN ready; many state applications ask for it.

Step 2: Decide employee or contractor before the first payday

The label in the contract does not decide this. The IRS looks at whether you have the right to control what will be done and how it will be done. A person can still be your employee even if they have freedom day to day, work part time, or invoice you.

If the person is an employee, you withhold income tax and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare tax, pay the employer share, deposit those taxes, and file payroll returns. If the person is a true independent contractor, those payroll steps generally do not apply, and you may instead have information-return duties later. Getting this wrong can mean back taxes and penalties.

If you are not sure, pause before the first payment and talk with your tax professional. The IRS can also make a determination if you file Form SS-8. This guide does not decide your worker's status.

Step 3: Complete new-hire paperwork and the new-hire report

Form W-4. Ask each new employee to complete the current Form W-4 so you can withhold federal income tax correctly. Keep the form with your payroll records.

Form I-9. You must verify that each new employee is legally eligible to work in the United States and complete Form I-9. The employee completes Section 1 no later than the first day of work for pay. You complete Section 2 within three business days of that first day. Get the form and the current instructions from USCIS I-9 Central, not from a reused copy.

State withholding form. Some states have their own employee withholding certificate. If yours does, collect it with the W-4.

New-hire report. All 50 states, and most territories, have a new-hire directory. You are required to report a new employee to the designated state registry. A new employee includes someone you have not employed before, or someone you rehired after a gap of at least 60 consecutive days. Many states accept a copy of Form W-4 with employer information added. Federal law gives you 20 days from the hire date; some states set a shorter deadline, so check your state's rule (federal new-hire reporting rules).

Record the name and Social Security number from the employee's Social Security card when it is available, and use that exact name and number on the W-2 later.

Step 4: Set a pay schedule, check workers' compensation, and post required notices

Pick a pay schedule and write it down. Choose the pay frequency (weekly, biweekly, semimonthly, or monthly) and the first payday, and tell the employee before work starts. State wage-payment laws can limit how long you may wait after a period is worked, so check your state if you are unsure.

Check workers' compensation. Most states require workers' compensation coverage once you have employees, including a first employee. A few states have exemptions for very small employers. This is state insurance law, not an IRS payroll form. Confirm the rule with your state's workers' compensation agency or your insurance professional before the first day of work.

Post the required federal and state notices. Federal and state labor agencies require certain workplace posters (minimum wage, family leave, unemployment, and others). Put them up where employees can see them. This is not a payroll tax filing, but it is part of being ready to have someone on staff.

If you will run payroll in a payroll system you already have, set up the new employee, the pay schedule, and the tax accounts there before the first run. You do not need a new payroll system to hire one person; you do need the accounts, the forms, and a way to withhold, deposit, and file on time.

Step 5: Run the first payroll and file the first quarterly returns

On each payday:

  1. Calculate gross wages for the period.
  2. Withhold federal income tax based on the W-4, plus the employee share of Social Security and Medicare tax.
  3. Withhold any state or local income tax.
  4. Deposit the withheld taxes and the employer share of Social Security and Medicare tax on the IRS deposit schedule that applies to you (monthly or semiweekly). Use EFTPS so you can confirm the deposit later.
  5. Give the employee a pay stub that shows wages, deductions, and the pay period.

After the close of each quarter (due April 30, July 31, October 31, and January 31, or the next business day if the date falls on a weekend or legal holiday), file federal Form 941 and the matching state withholding and unemployment returns, and pay any tax still due. Once a year you will also file Form 940 (federal unemployment), issue Form W-2, and file Form W-3 with the Social Security Administration. See IRS Publication 15 for the federal rules.

Keep payroll records at least four years, including your EIN, wages, dates, Forms W-4, deposit confirmations, and filed returns. Form I-9 has its own retention rule from USCIS.

Want a payroll team to handle the setup?

If you would rather have a payroll team do the setup, the first run, and the filings with you, book a time. For a wider look at ways to handle payroll as you grow, see payroll solutions for small businesses.

Get started

First-employee payroll checklist

Use this as a working list before the first payday:

EIN issued, and EFTPS enrollment started or complete

State withholding account open (if your state has withholding)

State unemployment account open

Worker classification decided (employee vs contractor) with your tax professional if needed

Form W-4 collected

Form I-9 Section 1 done by day one, Section 2 within three business days

State withholding form collected, if your state uses one

New-hire report sent to the state directory on time

Pay schedule and first payday agreed in writing

Workers' compensation coverage confirmed, if your state requires it

Required posters posted

First payroll calculated, reviewed, and paid

First federal and state deposits made through EFTPS and the state method

Quarterly Form 941 and state returns on the calendar

Hiring your first employee: payroll questions

What do I need to set up payroll for my first employee?

An EIN, EFTPS enrollment, state withholding and unemployment accounts, a completed Form W-4 and Form I-9, any state withholding form, a new-hire report to your state, a set pay schedule, and workers' compensation coverage if your state requires it. You also need a way to withhold, deposit, and file on time.

How long does it take to register for state payroll taxes?

It varies by state, and each state agency sets its own processing time. Start as soon as the hire is definite, and have your EIN ready. See the guide for your state on our state payroll tax registration page.

Do I need workers' comp for one employee?

Most states require workers' compensation coverage once you have employees, including a first employee. A few states exempt very small employers. Check your state's workers' compensation agency or your insurance professional before the first day of work.

When is the new-hire report due?

Federal law requires you to report a new hire to your state's new-hire directory within 20 days of the hire date. Some states set a shorter deadline, so use your state's rule if it is tighter. Many states accept a Form W-4 with your employer details added.

Should my first hire be an employee or a contractor?

That depends on whether you have the right to control how the work is done, not only what the contract calls the person. If you are not sure, talk with your tax professional before the first payment. Treating an employee as a contractor can mean back taxes and penalties.

Can someone set up payroll and register state accounts for me?

Yes. A payroll team can help you open or complete the tax accounts, collect the new-hire forms, run the first payroll, make the deposits, and file the quarterly returns. You still remain responsible, as the employer, for the taxes and filings. To talk it through, get started.

Sources

This guide explains common payroll setup steps for a first employee. It is not tax, legal, or insurance advice. Check your situation with your tax professional, your state agencies, and, for workers' compensation, your insurance professional.

PayAdvisors brand mark

Ready to set up payroll for your first employee?

If you want a payroll team to open the accounts, collect the new-hire forms, and run the first payday with you, pick a time.

Get started

Next step

Get the next pay run covered

Book a time, and tell us your next pay date and what you need.

We work with employers in all 50 states, and you approve every run.

Our team is here Monday through Friday.