Your Payroll Manager Quit: What to Do in the First 48 Hours

A business owner on a phone call at his desk

Secure every account payroll touches, find your next pay date and tax deposit deadline, and line up cover for the next two pay runs. PayAdvisors provides interim and emergency payroll support inside your current payroll system.

A team of payroll professionals can step in with your next pay run.

Your payroll person gave notice, or stopped coming in, and payday is on the calendar. What you do in the next 48 hours shapes the next pay run.

The first hour: secure access

Before anything else, make sure the company controls every account payroll touches.

  • Payroll system: confirm at least two admin users, then change or remove the departing person’s access.
  • Tax payment accounts: confirm who can log in to the accounts used for federal and state tax deposits.
  • State accounts: list each state where you withhold or pay unemployment tax, with its account number.
  • Bank and direct deposit: confirm who can approve payroll funding and the direct deposit file.
  • Pending changes: collect new hires, terminations, raises and deduction changes that were in progress.

Find the next deadlines

Start with the next pay date and the direct deposit submission deadline.

Then find your federal deposit schedule. Under IRS Publication 15 it generally depends on past tax liability, not pay frequency.

  • Monthly schedule: $50,000 or less of employment taxes in the lookback period. Deposit by the 15th of the following month.
  • Semiweekly schedule: more than $50,000. Wednesday to Friday paydays deposit by the following Wednesday; Saturday to Tuesday paydays by the following Friday.
  • Next-day rule: $100,000 or more accumulated on any day is due by the next business day.

Federal deposits are made electronically. State deadlines vary by state.

Cover the next two pay runs

Plan for two pay runs, not one. The first is urgent. The second is where gaps show up, because corrections from the first land on it.

OptionWhat it needsMain riskBest for
A coworker coversSomeone with time and system accessErrors from an untrained person; one more single point of failureOne short, simple pay run
A temp or contract hireRecruiting time and onboardingStill one person, with no review and no backupA long, predictable gap
An outside payroll teamSystem access and your payroll recordsHandoff takes some setupCoverage now, with review and backup
A permanent hireA search, often weeks or monthsPayroll still needs cover during the searchThe long term, if you want payroll in house

If payday is close, see emergency payroll support and the emergency payroll run checklist. Our team has a second payroll review built into our process and can stay on as your payroll team through payroll processing.

If payday is close

Our team has a second payroll review built into our process and can stay on as your payroll team.

See emergency payroll support

They gave notice: a two-week handover checklist

If they are still available for a handover, gather these before the last day:

  1. Write down every upcoming pay date, provider cutoff, federal deposit date and state filing due in the next 60 days.
  2. Confirm at least two company admin users in the payroll system, bank portal and tax accounts.
  3. List every state withholding and unemployment account, with login path and account number.
  4. Collect open garnishment orders (amount, payee, frequency) and benefit deduction maps.
  5. Document workarounds done outside the system (manual reports, one-off corrections).
  6. List open year-end items: W-2 or 1099 corrections and anything owed to an agency.
  7. Run one payroll together before the last day, with a second person reviewing the register.

If there is no handover, rebuild what you can from the payroll registers and agency notices, then cover the next pay run with the table above.

What usually lives only in one person’s head

Ask for these before the last day, or rebuild them from the payroll records:

Garnishments: each order, the amount and where the payment goes

Off-cycle runs and corrections: what was fixed by hand, and why

Workarounds: steps done outside the system to make a report or deduction come out right

State registrations: every state account, its number and its filing schedule

Benefit deductions: which carrier or plan each deduction pays, and when

Year-end items: open W-2 or 1099 corrections and anything owed to an agency

Should you replace them or hand payroll to a team?

You do not have to fill the role to keep payroll running. Compare the options in hire vs. outsource payroll. For a gap of weeks or months while you hire, see temporary payroll support. If they left or were let go and payday is close, see emergency payroll support. All situations: payroll help.

How fast can an outside payroll team take over?

We provide interim and emergency payroll support. Book a consultation to get started.

Frequently asked questions

What should I do first when my payroll person quits?

Secure admin access to your payroll system, tax accounts and bank approvals. Then find your next pay date and your next tax deposit deadline.

When is the next federal tax deposit due?

It depends on your deposit schedule. Monthly depositors deposit by the 15th of the following month; semiweekly depositors deposit within days of each payday (IRS Publication 15).

Can an outside team run payroll in our current payroll system?

Yes. PayAdvisors runs payroll inside the payroll system you already use, so nothing has to move.

Do we have to hire a replacement?

Not to keep payroll running. A payroll team can stay on as your payroll team, so you decide about the role on your own timeline.

Can you start before onboarding is finished?

Often, yes. We first assess your next pay date, system access, payroll records and provider cutoffs, then confirm whether we can cover the next run while onboarding continues.

How long does standard onboarding take?

Onboarding runs in phases. First, we learn your current payroll setup and processes. Next, our team takes over payroll in your payroll system and runs your first live payroll with you. After that, we move into ongoing payroll and look for ways to improve your setup.

My payroll manager gave two weeks notice. What should they hand over?

Use the two-week handover checklist above: pay calendar, admin users, state accounts, garnishments, workarounds, year-end items, and one supervised run before the last day.

Should I hire a new payroll manager or outsource payroll?

Either path works. An outside team can cover the next pay runs while you decide. See hire vs. outsource payroll and interim payroll services.

How fast can an outside payroll team take over?

We provide interim and emergency payroll support. Book a consultation to get started.

PayAdvisors brand mark

Talk to a payroll team about your next pay run

Last reviewed November 9, 2026. General information, not tax or legal advice for your situation.

Get started

Next step

Get the next pay run covered

Book a time, and tell us your next pay date and what changed.

We work with employers in all 50 states, and you approve every run.

Our team is here Monday through Friday.